Really Welsh Rarebit

  • Really Welsh Rarebit Recipe
  • 10-30 minutes to prepare
  • 60+ minutes to cook
  • Serves 4 adults and 1 baby
  • How to make

3 leeks
A knob of butter and a small splash of olive oil
100ml of cream 
A crunch of black pepper
100g 10-30 minutes tasty cheddar cheese
50g soft Welsh goats' cheese
1 tsp of mustard or 2 tbsp fresh thyme leaves (both optional)
9 slices fresh bread or 4 – 5 baked potatoes

Step 1

Chop off the bottom and tough green tops off the leeks. (The green tops can be kept for a day or two in the fridge and used to make a vegetable stock.) Finely slice the white part of the leeks then rinse in a sieve to remove dirt that has been trapped inside

Step 2

Sauté the leeks in butter and oil over medium/low heat for approx. 10 – 15 minutes until soft. Add in cream, black pepper and the mustard or fresh thyme if using. Allow the cream to gently bubble for another 5 minutes until thickened. Stir in the goats' cheese and cheddar for one minute and remove from the heat

Step 3

Toast the bread on one side then add cheesy topping to the untoasted side. Pop back under the grill until golden and bubbling

Step 4

Remove any hard crusts, if you have a little baby, and allow to cool. Ensure there are no hot spots inside the cheese that your little one could burn their mouth on. Cut into finger size pieces and allow your little one to chew and suck to their delight!

Step 5

If topping jacket potatoes, simply rub potatoes with a little olive oil, prick several times with a fork and bake at 200ºC for approx. 1 hour. Once baked, cut in half, fluff up potato with a fork, add the cheesy topping and grill for about 5 minutes. These again can be cut into fingers, always ensuring they are not too hot in the centre and under the cheese for baby


  • Gluten ingredients
  • Wheat
  • Dairy ingredients
  • Mustard

Print this recipe

Recipe notes

For a gluten free option, serve on top of freshly baked potatoes – very tasty Cut into fingers, this recipe makes a great finger food for your little ones.

More tasty recipes to try